Rough Draft of Genre Analysis on Subject of Antibiotic Resistance
Antibiotic resistance is at the forefront of research investigation. What goes on in laboratories in this nation and across the globe sometimes gets missed in every day activity. The populace at large has resources that can clue them in to this ongoing medical crisis. The following discussion provides an analysis of popular and professional audience perspectives on this issue. How they portray their structure, style, content, and language is important to the purpose of the message they present.
On the popular corner I found CNN's MRSA: Protect Your Kid from a Superbug," which focused on a 2 year old girl who experienced exposure to MRSA. (Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus)1 In a New York Times web article, "Free Antibiotics May Contribute to Drug Resistance Officials Say," the CDC got involved by warning the pharmacies that offering free treatments of antibiotics may encourage stockpiling and eventual resistance in the community.2 In Wikipedia a long profile under Antibacterials provided more scientific knowledge about the cause of resistance, how bacteria acquire it in their DNA structure, and an example of antibiotic misuse.3
The professional treatment of antibiotic resistance in "Update in Antifungal Drug Resistance: Mechanisms of Aspergillus fumigatus,"4 and Single-nucleotide Polymorphism-based differentiation and drug resistance detection in Mycobacterium tuberculosis from Isolates or Directly from Sputum,"5 targets the laboratory research on the forefront of this issue. Both scientific journals provided introductory abstracts followed by a detailed workup of the testing done. The journals utilized data structured in filed comparison form, tables, and graphs of the specific microorganism involved in their study.
In detailing each genre, typical patterns of information and audience specific language occurred. CNN's article raised awareness of the community at large of the presence of MRSA. By use of the 2 year old girls' picture, her parents' interview, and a statement from the CDC, CNN merged the emotional side of the problem, the data gathered by the parents about the microbe, and the authoritative side from the CDC. Her parents mistook what they thought was a pimple, when it was MRSA. One day it looked as if it was indeed a pimple, but the next day it was painful and reddened, with their daughter experiencing a high fever as well. Dr. Patrick Romano was quoted as stating,"The number of children hospitalized with MRSA infections, mostly acquired from within the community, has more than doubled since 2000."1 CNN offered guidelines for patents about what they should know and recognize about MRSA infections. Those guidelines were directed from the ISDA (Infectious Diseases Society of America). The discourse lasted two and a half pages, and presented a comment area at the end of the web article.
The New York Times article conveyed two problems. The CDC encouraged the pharmacies who were giving out free antibiotics to rethink their offers. They also suggested the companies would better serve the public by offering free vaccines. Even though the public still needed a prescription to fill the free drug item, the CDC was concerned presenting such a program during the cold and flu season may promote the problem of antibiotic resistance. Colds and flu are caused primarily by viruses and antibiotics and are of no use in that situation. People however still seek out a physician who will prescribe them one for treatment when none is indicated. This phenomenon was felt by Dr. Anne Gershon of the IDSA, when she stated, "Giving away antibiotics could lead to stockpiling of drugs."2 Another usual problem seen is while patients are taking an antibiotic, they stop using it when they feel better, which in the long run can also promote the mutation of left over bacteria to more resistant forms. This short journal offered mostly an informative appeal.
In Wikipedia's profile on Antibacterials, they provided under a subsection called Resistance and Misuse an in depth look at how bacteria hijack other DNA material.3 They utilized pictures of DNA elements and the structures bacteria use to incorporate other microbial material. One noted misuse of antibiotics was the livestock industry's use of drugs to increase the weight of their animals at market. I feel this is unethical. Europe was noted to have outlawed this practice. The Senate and House bills Wikipedia provided did not denote whether any laws were passed recently on this issue.
It takes more time to read and interpret the two professional journals I found. Technologists in laboratory medicine, particularly those in microbiology and mycology (study of fungus) would find a plethora of data on drug resistance. They must have a background or knowledge of DNA sequencing and the current techniques for molecular diagnostic testing. The one journal on tuberculosis was quite thorough in its discussion of the disease, the TB bacteria which causes the problem, and the various technical applications utilized to test certain gene mutations related to resistance. The aim was to find a rapid screening procedure that could be used directly on a patients' sample.5 The turnaround time for results would provide the physician with a better insight on whether the patients' strain of bacteria is resistant to certain drug protocol for TB.
The second journal on fungus described the overall battle to find new drugs to combat resistant fungi which primarily cause invasive aspergillosis (IA).4 This journal was a complete overview of current anti-fungals and their resistance patterns. The causative agent Aspergillus fumigatus was explored at each level with schematics of mutant gene sites, patterns of resistance, and other scientific nomenclature that would be too complex to discuss in this moment of time. The layout of the journal was excellent as it was subdivided into categories related to the fungus. If one were interested in a particular part of the journal's study then all that information was found in one area.
Summarily both the popular and the professional genres obviously differ in their language, layout, and their overall motivation. Popular search and news engines like CNN and Wikipedia are informative in their rhetorical appeal. They must provide a broad stance in order for the public at large to comprehend their stories and articles. However in this case of antibiotic resistance, it doesn't eliminate the seriousness of the subject. The approach by way of language must be understood in simpler terms. They too can provide authoritative citations as the popular articles I mentioned above. On the professional side, the medical researchers involved in the battle to find new antibiotics utilize their scientific forums and journals to keep updated on their side of the issue. Although these researchers may not be on the minds of the public on a daily basis, they are nevertheless concerned with the same problem as the public. Both audiences must stay aware and alert to issues like MRSA and TB resistant microbes. Each audience therefore will find a venue, (whether CNN or the next issue of American Journal of Microbiology) to stay on top of the problem of antibiotic resistance.
Works Cited
- Rice, S. CNN Medical Producer. MRSA: Protect Your Kid from a Superbug. 8 Sep 2011 Available from http://www.cnn.com/2011/09/01/health/child-mrsa-infections/index.html Downloaded 17 Oct 2011
- Parker-Pope,T. Free Antibiotics May Contribute to Drug Resistance, Officials Say. New York Times. 2009 Mar 5 Available from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/05/health/policy/05drugs.html Downloaded 17 Oct 2011
- Antibacterials: Resistance and Misuse. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, pages 1-16 Available at http://en.wikipedia.org.wiki/Antibacterial Downloaded 15 Oct 2011
- Chamilos, G., Kontoyiannis, D.P. Drug Resistance Updates 8 (2005) 344-358. Aspergillus
fumigatus, An Update on anti-fungal drug resistance mechanisms, Elsevier Ltd. Available online at www.sciencedirect.com or www.elsevier.com/locate/drop Downloaded and on PDF from http://blackboard.uc.edu (Electronic Journal Center) 18 Oct 2011
- Arnold, C., Westland, L., Mowat, G., Underwood, A., Magee, J., Gharbia, S." Single-nucleotide polymorphism-based differentiation and drug resistance detection in Mycobacterium
tuberculosis from isolates or directly from sputum." Clinical Microbiology Infectious 2005: 11: 122-130. Journal allowed reprint from European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases. Downloaded and on PDF from http://blackboard.uc.edu (Electronic Journal Center) 18 Oct 2011